Etsy’s New Direction: Top Alternatives for Handmade Sellers
Etsy, the once go-to platform for handmade and vintage items, has significantly shifted its focus. To compete with retail giants like Temu and Amazon, Etsy has redefined its product classifications. We’ll explores Etsy’s changes, community reactions, and alternative platforms for artists selling handmade work.
Etsy’s New Product Classifications: What You Need to Know
Etsy’s recent policy update has introduced four new product classifications:
- Made by: Items created by the seller, such as handmade ceramics or jewelry.
- Designed by: Products designed by the seller but produced by a third party, like digital illustrations or print-on-demand items.
- Handpicked by: Curated vintage items selected by the seller.
- Sourced by: Craft supplies and materials.
These categories are meant to provide transparency, but they also signify a departure from Etsy’s original focus on handmade and vintage items. Over the years, Etsy has allowed sellers to use outside production help, diluting the platform’s unique, handcrafted essence.
Community Reaction: Artisans Express Frustration
Etsy’s policy changes have sparked frustration among its core user base — independent artisans and vintage curators. Many sellers feel that Etsy’s leniency towards resellers and drop shippers has undermined the platform’s authenticity. The 2022 seller strike highlighted these concerns, with creators demanding stricter enforcement of handmade policies.
Moreover, the rise of AI-generated content, often falsely advertised as handmade, has further complicated the landscape. Etsy’s new categories aim to reassure both shoppers and creators that their purchases are authentic and human-made.
Alternatives to Etsy for Selling Handmade Goods
For artists seeking platforms that stay true to the handmade ethos, several alternatives stand out:
1. Amazon Handmade — https://sell.amazon.com/programs/handmade
Amazon Handmade is a dedicated section of Amazon that focuses on handmade items. It provides a vast audience reach and the reliability of Amazon’s infrastructure.
- Pros: Large customer base, robust fulfillment options, trusted platform.
- Cons: Higher competition, commission fees, stringent application process.
2. Bonanza — https://www.bonanza.com/
Bonanza is an easy-to-use platform for selling a wide variety of items, including handmade goods. It emphasizes simplicity and seller-friendly policies.
- Pros: Low fees, easy to set up, integrated with other e-commerce platforms.
- Cons: Smaller audience compared to major marketplaces, less brand recognition.
3. UncommonGoods — https://www.uncommongoods.com/
UncommonGoods focuses on unique and creatively designed products, offering a great platform for artists and artisans to reach customers looking for distinctive items.
- Pros: Niche market for unique goods, strong emphasis on sustainability, supportive community.
- Cons: Higher standards for product approval, competitive application process.
4. RebelsMarket — https://www.rebelsmarket.com/
RebelsMarket caters to alternative fashion and unique, edgy products, making it an ideal platform for artists with a distinct style.
- Pros: Niche market, supportive seller community, no listing fees.
- Cons: Limited to alternative and edgy styles, smaller audience compared to mainstream platforms.
5. Big Cartel — https://www.bigcartel.com/
Big Cartel is perfect for independent artists looking to create their own branded online store. It’s easy to set up and offers customizable themes.
- Pros: Customizable storefronts, no listing fees, artist-focused.
- Cons: Limited to 500 products, fewer built-in marketing tools.
6. Shopify — https://www.shopify.com/
Shopify allows artisans to build a fully customizable online store with extensive marketing and sales analytics tools.
- Pros: Highly customizable, robust e-commerce tools, scalable for growing businesses.
- Cons: Monthly subscription fees, steeper learning curve for beginners.
7. Storenvy — https://www.storenvy.com/
Storenvy combines a marketplace with individual storefronts, emphasizing unique and indie products.
- Pros: Combination of marketplace and standalone stores, no listing fees.
- Cons: Less traffic than Etsy, commission on sales.
8. Redbubble — https://www.redbubble.com/
Redbubble is a popular print-on-demand platform where artists can sell prints, clothing, stickers, and more with their designs. It handles the production, shipping, and customer service.
- Pros: Easy to use, wide range of products, passive income potential.
- Cons: Lower profit margins, less control over product quality.
9. Society6 — https://society6.com/
Society6 offers artists a platform to sell their artwork as prints, home decor, apparel, and more. Like Redbubble, it handles production and fulfillment.
- Pros: Wide range of products, artist-friendly policies, passive income potential.
- Cons: Lower profit margins, competitive market.
10. Fine Art America — https://fineartamerica.com/
Fine Art America is tailored for artists wanting to sell fine art prints, home decor, apparel, and other products. It offers comprehensive marketing tools and print-on-demand services.
- Pros: Focus on fine art, extensive marketing tools, print-on-demand.
- Cons: Monthly subscription fee for premium features, competitive market.
Conclusion: Navigating the New Etsy Landscape
Etsy’s evolution reflects broader e-commerce trends, balancing artisanal authenticity with competitive pressures from mass retailers. The new product classifications aim to enhance transparency and trust but also mark a departure from Etsy’s original handmade and vintage exclusivity. For artists and vintage sellers seeking platforms that align with their values, exploring alternatives like Amazon Handmade, Bonanza, UncommonGoods, RebelsMarket, Big Cartel, Shopify, Storenvy, Redbubble, Society6, and Fine Art America can provide new avenues to showcase their unique creations and connect with like-minded buyers.
As Etsy navigates this crucial moment, the challenge remains to retain its identity while adapting to an ever-changing market. For sellers, staying informed and adaptable will be key to thriving in this evolving landscape.
FAQs
What are Etsy’s new product classifications?
Etsy’s new product classifications include “made by,” “designed by,” “handpicked by,” and “sourced by.” These aim to provide more transparency about how products are made and the seller’s involvement.
Why are Etsy sellers frustrated with the new changes?
Many Etsy sellers feel that the platform’s leniency towards resellers and drop shippers undermines the authenticity of handmade items. The influx of mass-produced goods and AI-generated content has further complicated the landscape.
What are some alternatives to Etsy for selling handmade goods?
Alternatives to Etsy include Amazon Handmade, Bonanza, UncommonGoods, RebelsMarket, Big Cartel, Shopify, Storenvy, Redbubble, Society6, and Fine Art America. These platforms offer various features that cater to artists and handmade sellers, providing more control and authenticity.
Like what you see? Follow us on Instagram, Threads, and TikTok. If you’re a brand, you can collab with us through Passionfroot. If you want to support our work, buy us a coffee.
